For the source text click/tap here: Chullin 14
To download, click/tap here: PDF
According to the Mishna on our daf if someone performs sheḥita (ritual slaughter) on an animal on Shabbat or on Yom Kippur, although the act of killing an animal on those days is forbidden and the person who performs sheḥita is liable to receive a death penalty, nevertheless the animal is kosher and can be eaten.
Rav Huna quotes Ḥiyya bar Rav in the name of Rav as teaching that the animal may be kosher, but it still cannot be eaten on that day. This was understood by the Sages as an indication that Rav understood the Mishna as following the opinion of Rabbi Yehuda.
Our Daf confronts a question whose apparent simplicity belies its conceptual depth: what is the ontological and halakhic status of a living animal during its lifetime? Is it intrinsically directed toward eventual consumption — baʽalei chayim be-chayeihem omedim le-akhilah — such that even while alive it is already, in some legally meaningful sense, prepared for the table? Or is its primary teleological orientation breeding, growth, and continued life — omedim le-giddul, or, as some authorities frame it, omedim le-velad — such that slaughter, when it occurs, constitutes a categorical disruption of the animal’s standing designation rather than its fulfilment?
We explore this them as well as Karate interpretations.