For the source text click/tap here: Bechorot 58
To download, click/tap here: PDF
The final chapter of tractate Bekhorot introduces us to one of the most curious rituals in the biblical economy of holiness. The owner of a flock gathers the newborn animals into an enclosure, constructs a narrow opening through which they may emerge only one at a time, and begins to count. One, two, three, four, until the tenth animal passes beneath the rod. That animal is marked with red pigment and declared holy.
We learn how contrasting methods of designating the ma'aser. Regarding ma'aser beheima, the specific animals designated as ma'aser beheima must be chosen via a process of counting. As one enumerates the flock one marks every tenth animal, thus awarding it the status of ma'aser beheima. This process reflects at least a technical difference between this ma'aser and the ma'aser sheni taken from crops. Regarding the latter, there is no act of counting, rather it is the direct designation of the ma'aser itself, which defines the remainder as non-ma'aser, thereby permitting it. Counting on the other hand, begins with the first nine objects, which are not ma’aser.
The distinction between a certain and uncertain tenth becomes a distinction between legitimate designation and unsupported assertion.
In Bava Batra 22a, we explore an aggadah concerning Rav Adda bar Abba: where the scholar becomes the gatekeeper.
