For the source text click/tap here: Bechorot 61
To download, click/tap here: PDF
We learned that if ninth or eleventh animals are mistakenly called "tenth," they become sanctified. However, this is only true when one tithes himself. If someone sent an agent to tithe his flock, and the agent miscounted, calling the ninth or the eleventh animal "tenth", then the ninth is indeed sanctified, but the eleventh is not - these are the words of Rav Pappi.
Rav Pappa disagrees and says that neither the ninth nor the eleventh become sanctified, because the owner can tell the agent, "I sent you to benefit me, not to harm me, therefore your agency is void." And Rav Pappi? He says that when the agent called the ninth animal "tenth", his agency was still in power, he only lost it after this action, and tithe sanctified in error still counts.
W explore the work of Moshe Kline in his structural approach to Mishna however Bekhorot is a hard test case, and that makes it a good one. The Encyclopaedia Judaica entry calls the tractate a striking instance of the weaving together of disparate strands to form a mishnaic tractate. The strands are four: the firstborn of the donkey, the firstborn of the clean animal, the human firstborn, and the animal tithe, which is not a firstborn law at all. A literary hypothesis that claims every chapter is "tightly woven" should either show the weave here or break down.
