Julian Ungar-Sargon

  • Home
  • Theological Essays
  • Healing Essays
  • Podcast
  • Poetry
  • Daf Ditty
  • Deep Dive Ditty
  • Videos
  • Publications
  • Military Service
  • Dominican University
  • Home
  • Theological Essays
  • Healing Essays
  • Podcast
  • Poetry
  • Daf Ditty
  • Deep Dive Ditty
  • Videos
  • Publications
  • Military Service
  • Dominican University

Poems

Moving Poetry by Dr. Julian Ungar-Sargon

The Theology of Gaza

jyungar August 12, 2014

The siren sounds in my twin sister’s back yard

as I sip her fine scotch

and listen to my hero nephew speak of blood and war.

I was told to listen to the direction of its trajectory

and worry if it comes from the south

and run to the “safe room”

But I am in Jerusalem

Surely they are not that accurate to risk

sending rockets to where their brethren share the Holy City?

I wonder what my mother thinks at 90 years

arriving in London 1941,

lying on her bed during those terrible nights in the Blitz

as Hitler’s “doodlebugs” (the V1 rockets)

primitive versions, had just enough fuel to reach London

living in fear the humming engine carrying the bomb

would stop-signifying a vertical gravity drop

on the buildings of citizens.

Here too these primitive devices end their trajectory

and just fall dead straight.

But today as I return home,

my heart is in Zhitomer

a tiny village in the Ukraine

making its name felt on the front page

announcing the rescue of its Jews

by the Jewish Agency ad their transfer to Israel.

Yet again…

Cossacks, Russians, Nazis, Ukrainian National Guards,

Eizatzgruppen….memories…

now Ukrainian right wing fascists, the new government

their descendants…

Zhitomer ah…the name sends shudders

down the spine of book collectors like me…

a city that holds the Tzion of the Rebbe Reb Zisha,

Zhitomer ah…

the printing press that took over

after the brothers Schapira

(grandchildren of the Rebbe Reb Pinchas of Koretz)

who were forced to run the gauntlet by the Tzar’s army,

and were taken away to exile

closing the Slovita printing press

and moving it to…yes, Zhitomer.

Now house to the printing of many 19th century great works

(in competition with its more powerful press run by the brothers Romm)

Once again Jews flee

but the Israeli government

has their backs covered this time,

God Bless them

they are coming to Israel on Aliyah.

Safe from the fascists

they’ll only have to contend with rockets and air raid sirens now.

The Cossacks have come again

Russian separatists, Ukrainian Nationalists?

it matters not,

Jews are no longer safe.

But my heart belongs in these little shtetleich,

Zhitomer, Mezhibuz, Breslov, Berditchev

where the romance of Hassidut housed

the “Pauline Revolution” within hidebound orthodoxy.

Where the heart, not the mind, was placed

at center of religious life and worship.

Where the revolution against fundamentalism,

dogma, doctrine and frumkeit…

by the Talmidim of the Baal Shem Tov flourished

where Jews were powerless in the body politic but masters of spirit,

where I still sense their spirit on my pilgrimages

and can find a little solace out of my own headspace.

Meanwhile in GAZA the bleeding goes on…

the images craftily used by HAMAS for PR purposes

are winning the hearts of the citizens of the world…

and CNN drinks from their fountain without objectivity.

Yet despite all the media and contrived images on social networks

despite even the unrepresented righteousness of our cause

these bleeding men women and children haunt me at night

as a Jew.

And the tears for the loss of the divine image in man

(no matter his religion or passion)

his madness or fanaticism

are shed upstairs

For the god of all religions MUST be crying no?

or what type of a deity is He, right?

these tears

ring in my heart and soul.

War…

its consequences

the collateral damage

the lives

the cost

for the sake of real estate?

really?

human blood for real estate?

like Rwanda? Northern Ireland? Cherkvenitzia?

now Gaza?

The winds of fanaticism once again

whatever the faith doctrine dogma

leave a trail of blood everywhere in their path

drops of blood forming rivers in the memory

of peoples and cultures,

ordinary citizens,

with no interest or choice in this ideological warfare.

I leave the Middle East with a heavy heart

heavily invested in my tradition

but bleeding in my heart for the blood

that has run through the streets of Gaza

and for our valiant boys

who innocently protected the homeland

30000 attend the funeral of one bright faced abductee

the public display of cohesive mourning is overwhelming.

Jerusalem is silent

the tourists fled

the streets participate in the mourning.

The complexity of Jewish history I’ll leave to Rabbi Wein

or other Art Scroll philosophers,

All I feel now is the pain of the mothers

who lost their children on both sides,

and the blood of the innocents,

all I feel now is God’s pain,

or that of the Shechinah.

Born 5 years after the Tremendum

I remain haunted

by the blood of the innocents…

the millions who died on both sides of the World Wars

screaming out to me

millions and millions

from the blood soaked soil of Europe

this is my haunting…

these are my dreams

their memory,

And still nothing new

And nothing learned

noting gained

The blood still runs easily

and Human Life is valued no more

all is sacrificed for the sake of ideology dogma and doctrine

in the name of a NEW WAVE OF FUNDAMENTALISM

needing perhaps a new message?

a new corrective?

a new Crusade perhaps.

This virus…

This war…

points to the demonic,

(how else to explain the thirst for blood and torture?)

alive and well in the hearts of men

Sammael was right (in that Yemenite Midrash)

his son Cain…

born of his fornication with Mother Eve…

Cain, now spoke within the heart of men,

he had accomplished his father’s task.

Despite Adam’s attempt to slice him into pieces and devour him,

Despite the League of Nations and the UN

and all the resolutions from the East River,

nothing has changed.

The heart remains infected with this virus.

Only the method of killing and torture has changed

the technology of the killing fields

drone warfare

and Laser Beams.

Yes, I leave Israel

with a heavy heart

(bleeding liberal I am),

for the blood that cries out from the earth of the Holy Land

the silent brave screams of those young soldiers who died in vain

and the memories of Slovita, Zhitomer, Cossacks and Nazis

and now Hamas, Holy Jihad, ISIS,

whose lessons we failed to learn

that all blood is red, now co-mingled once again in pain.

All mothers cry and die inside for their sons

either side of the fence, the wall, the border,

it’s always been that way

the children of Gaza were innocent

as were the non-combatants.

But for some doctrine, dogma or holy belief

on both sides…

that deifies and fetishizes real estate

and prefer the Napoleonic theory of “sovereign statehood”

and worship of the outdated senile European notion of states

over unique new solutions

in this world of cyberspace and global commerce that knows of no borders.

Really? Can’t we create a post modern “No State” solution?

One that refuses borders and killing machines, that “federalizes land?

Let’s return to

an experimental village type

co-existence.

Defy modernity

It brought only death.

It is not the religious divide that makes this solution impossible

it is the notion of modernity ending (we had hoped)

but still not ending, with Auschwitz

that allows for ongoing genocide war and torture.

Only when enough blood has spilled

only then, exhausted from the hemorrhage,

will both sides sit together.

Will mothers grieve finally

Until then we watch from our smartphones and screens

the networks vying for closer and closer immediacy to the frontline

reporters and photo crews “embedded”

filming, filming the ER and hospitals

the results of collateral damage

that deadens our sensitivity even further

every war…deeper into the blood,

as if CNN and BBC and Fox and AL Jazeera

are themselves complicit in allowing us

this voyeuristic juissance of blood-stained victims.

Religion and Technology

Warfare and Modernity

combine in this perfect storm

to deaden us to the real human pain

and provide a foil for the true issues

that the human heart is broken

filled with the demonic.

As if political posturing and brinkmanship

will do other than “kick the ball down the road”

So I am alone,

torn between my double refutation of the politics

and the fundamentalist delusion that

somehow our sins are an impediment to progress

that the Imminent coming of the Messiah

or the Qura’nic jihadist promises of 70 Virgins

might do anything other than harm human kindness and progress

or end the violence.

TagsP4
  • Poems
  • Older
  • Newer

Julian Ungar-Sargon

This is Julian Ungar-Sargon's personal website. It contains poems, essays, and podcasts for the spiritual seeker and interdisciplinary aficionado.​