Sukkah 5: Schechina

For the source text click/tap here: Sukkah 5

To download, click/tap here: PDF

In a midrashic analysis of the source for the minimum acceptable height of a sukkah (ten tefachim), the Gemara looks to the height of the aron – the ark containing the luhot ha-berit (the tablets of the covenant) – which was ten tefachim high. It is clear from the Biblical description that the aron was nine tefahim high; the additional tefah was the height of the kaporet that covered the aron.

The Gemora says that the Divine presence never descended below 10 tefachim, and no person ever ascended above 10 tefachim. The Maharatz Chiyus explains this allegorically to mean that Hashem grants all people free will. Therefore, He does not intervene in their actions in this world, effectively “remaining” in the upper realm. Even when Moshe and Eliyahu ascended, they didn't lose their human identity. Therefore, the angels asked Hashem what a human being was doing among them, and Eliyahu would appear as a person to the Sages.

This leads us to an exploration of the meaning of the term Schechina and how it developed through the kabbalistic and hassidic tradition.

Sukkah 4: Rishon le-Cheshbon Avonot

For the source text click/tap here: Sukkah 4

To download, click/tap here: PDF

We witness the creation and finalization of halachot in our daf. First we learn about raising the floor of a sukka to decrease its height. Next we learn about shade and sagging roofs. Then platforms within the sukka are considered. We look at "curved walls" and at dug out portions of a sukka floor. In most of these cases, the rabbis turn to related case law to determine these halachot. After deciding how/whether that case law should apply to their current question, the rabbis state when a sukka is fit and when it is unfit.

Thinking still, about the Maseches Succah following Yoma….

We are told to fix the succah immediately after Yom Kippur without delay… which leads us to the enigmatic statement: Rishon the lecheshbon avonos

and the sweet Torah of Rav Levi Yitzchak Mi berditchev (Kedushas levi) as to the nature of the transition which we undergo as we proceed from the Yamim Nora’im to Sukkot.

Sukkah 3: Smallest Dimension

For the source text click/tap here: Sukkah 3

To download, click/tap here: PDF

Aside from the discussion in the Mishnah with regard to the height of a sukkah, there is also a need to define the minimum size of a sukkah. The Gemara on our daf presents a discussion between Bet Hillel and Bet Shammai, in which they agree that it must be large enough to fit a person’s head and the majority of his body (rosho ve-rubo), but they disagree on whether there is cause for concern that he will lean out of the sukkah if the table is placed outside. According to Bet Hillel this is not something that we fear will happen; so as long as rosho ve-rubo fit, the sukkah is fine. Bet Shamai rules that this is a concern, so we must make the sukkah large enough to contain the table, as well.

We explore the joys of Succot in LA and Jerusalem through the lens of unlikely writers including the story of the Deller Succah and its miraculous voyage out of Nazi Germany...the Deller sukkah was considered unique already at the beginning of the 20th century, and today, stands out as one of very few known sukkahs to have survived the Holocaust with its paintings intact.

We end with an imaginary spoof on Dr Who!

Sukkah 2: Dimensions

For the source text click/tap here: Sukkah 2

To download, click/tap here: PDF

The Gemara presents four opinions for why a Sukkah taller than 20 Amos is Pasul. There are practical differences between these opinions with regard to whether there are exceptions to the Pesul of a Sukkah taller than 20 Amos, and under what circumstances those exceptions apply.

We explore the dimensions of the succah and the inner dimension of Succah as a metaphor for life per R Simon Jacobson (always true to his Chabad worldview)

and the curious phenomenon of Dutch Christians celebrating Sukkot in a suburb of The Hague called Pijnacker….

Yoma 88: Ne’ilah

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 88

To download, click/tap here: PDF

Rav maintains that Ne'ilah is recited at night, and it replaces the Tefilah of Ma'ariv. The Gemara shows that the Tana of a Beraisa disagrees with Rav and says that Ne'ilah is recited before nightfall and does not replace Ma'ariv. The Gemara defends Rav's opinion and says that the time at which Ne'ilah is recited is the subject of a Machlokes Tana'im, and Rav follows the Tana who rules that Ne'ilah is recited at night.

In the context of defining what comprises the special Ne’ilah prayer on Yom Kippur, the Gemara on our daf brings a baraita that discusses people who go to the mikvah to immerse themselves on Yom Kippur.

We explore a number of writers on Ne'ilah and its effect on our spiritual process ending with a smooth transition into Succos and our next tractate.

Yoma 87: Sin and Addiction

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 87

To download, click/tap here: PDF

The conclusion of Tractate Yoma this week brought Daf Yomi readers face to face with the heart of Yom Kippur: repentance.

For months now, we have learned about the color of the high priest’s robes and how to sacrifice a goat to Azazel. Most of these matters concern the ordinary Jew not at all, and the overall picture of Yom Kippur that one gets from the Talmud feels very far from the holiday as we experience it today. But now, at the culmination of the whole tractate, the rabbis zero in on the spiritual and ethical questions that concern us most. How exactly does Yom Kippur achieve atonement for our sins?

What steps must we take to show that repentance is sincere?

Rav Chisda teaches that we must apologize in three ways: We say, I have sinned, I perverted what was right, my sin did not profit me", as taken from Job 33:27. Rabbi Yosei bar Chanina agrees with the three part apology, but he suggests, "please, please forgive my transgression, and now please forgive", this idea taken from Genesis 50:17.

“Please, please forgive the transgression of your brothers and their sin, for they did evil to you. And now, please forgive”

If we owe money, we must pay that money back. If the wronged person dies before accepting our apology, the apology is repeated at his gravesite with ten people as witnesses.

This leads us to the Difference in Obligation of Bein Adam Le-chavero and Bein Adam La-Makom, an essay by Rav Zimmerman... and an exploration of repentance and forgiveness and the parallels between the 12 step program and penitence.

Yoma 86: Pardons All Around (Except Acher)

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 86

To download, click/tap here: PDF

As we approach the end of Masechet Yoma, the Gemara turns to the most essential issue of this holy day – the atonement offered by Yom Kippur itself and the teshuva – repentance – associated with this time of year.

In a series of statements of Amoraim praising the attributes of teshuva, two statements made by Resh Lakish (who was, himself, a famous ba’al teshuva) are presented. In one of them Resh Lakish argues (based on the passage in Hoshea 14:2) that teshuva changes zedonot – sinful acts done on purpose – to shegagot – acts done by accident. In the second statement, (based on Yechezkel 33:19) he teaches that through the good offices of teshuva, zedonot are turned into zekhuyot – positive attributes.

To answer this apparent contradiction, the Gemara distinguishes between teshuva that is done because of love – when zedonot turn into zekhuyot – and when it is done out of fear of punishment – when zedonot become shegagot.

We examine the notion of Atonement and Pardon, and the exceptions, most notably Elisha ben Abuya or Acher and why he was refused pardon.

How does Milton Steinberg's account (albeit fictional) differ from the texts we inhabit? (as a Driven Leaf)

Yoma 85: Selicha, Mechila, and Kappara

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 85

To download, click/tap here: PDF

Finally we arrive at the concept of atonement and forgiveness!!

“The ritual bath of Israel is God” Just as a ritual bath purifies the impure, so too, the Holy One, blessed be He, purifies Israel.....is it the day which purifies or the effort?

We explore a number of commentators and the metaphor of the mikveh...and Rebbe's outrageous claim "It was taught: Rabbi says: For all sins in the Torah, whether one repents or not – the Day of Atonement atones, except for one who throws off the yoke, offends regarding Torah, or revokes his carnal covenant, where if one repents—the Day of Atonement atones, and if not—the Day of Atonement does not atone."

Finally the Qumran Pesher Habakuk' diatribe against the "wicked Kohen Gadol" in the Temple!

Yoma 84: Medicine and Halacha

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 84

To download, click/tap here: PDF

A number of illnesses are discussed on our daf.  What might have been hepatitis; what may have been diphtheria.  Treatments, including bloodletting, are mentioned as well.  At issue is the treatment of illness on Shabbat. The rabbis agree that an illness must be life-threatening for a person to administer medicine on Shabbat.  They argue about which illnesses are in fact life-threatening. 

We explore medicine in the talmud from Pikuach nefesh and Shabbat (Rav Lichtenstein) to the influence of Galen on the Rabbis and the struggle between medicine and religion in the Rambam by Elinor Lieber.  

Yoma 83: Bulmus and Anorexia

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 83

To download, click/tap here: PDF

In the case of one who is seized with the life-threatening illness bulmos, causing him unbearable hunger pangs and impaired vision, one may feed him even impure foods on Yom Kippur or any other day until his eyes recover, as the return of his sight indicates that he is recovering.

The rabbis consider illnesses, including confusion or tunba (seemingly senility or dementia), and bulmos. Bulmos, which has the same root as bulimia (Ancient Greek for 'excessive hunger') is a condition that includes symptoms of excessive hunger and loss of vision. The eyes recover first as a person heals from bulmos.

The term bulimia comes from Greek βουλιμία boulīmia, "ravenous hunger",

Although diagnostic criteria for bulimia nervosa did not appear until 1979, evidence suggests that binging and purging were popular in certain ancient cultures. The first documented account of behavior resembling bulimia nervosa was recorded in Xenophon's Anabasis around 370 B.C, in which Greek soldiers purged themselves in the mountains of Asia Minor. It is unclear whether this purging was preceded by binging.

we explore the syndrome of Anorexia vs bulimia ...and modern techniques to manage this deadly disease affecting young people.

Yoma 82: The Pregnancy and Pikuach Nefesh

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 82

To download, click/tap here: PDF

Included in the cases of life-saving taking precedence over the laws of Yom Kippur is that of an expectant mother whose unborn child smells food. If the resulting desire to taste that food is not satisfied, the lives of both mother and child are in danger. The mishna therefore tells us that she must be given to eat from that food until she recovers.

The saving of life overrides any commandment. Our Daf (Yoma 82a) explains that nothing stands in the way of “pikuach nefesh”, saving a life, other than the cardinal sins of idol worship, illicit relations or murder.

An Israeli study found that during the Day of Atonement, Jews had twice as many preterm deliveries.

To investigate why, they matched data on deliveries at the hospital from 1988 to 2012 with the Jewish calendar. Of the mothers, 388 were Jewish and 357 were Bedouin. Forty-seven, or 6.3 percent, of the births were premature, or earlier than 37 weeks after conception.

Yoma 81: Erev Yom Kippur

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 81

To download, click/tap here: PDF

Four different reasons are given for the mitzvah to eat on Erev Yom Kippur. Rabbeinu Yonah (1) records three of those reasons.

The first reason is to show the great joy of knowing that the time for our atonement has arrived.

A second explanation is that on other Yomim Tovim there is a meal to celebrate the joy of the mitzvos but since on Yom Kippur we cannot have that meal we hold it on Erev Yom Kippur.

A third rationale is to strengthen our bodies before the fast. Hashem knows that fasting is difficult and therefore, commanded us to eat the day before Yom Kippur, in order to ease the affliction (2)

The last reason is recorded in Shibolei Haleket. He writes that the reason for the mitzvah to eat on Erev Yom Kippur is to make the fast more difficult (the opposite of the previous explanation). There are a number of practical ramifications that emerge from these different reasons. One case would be a person who is ill and will eat on Yom Kippur.

The Eliya Rabbah (Rav Eliyahu Shapira’s gloss on the Shulchan Arukh) suggests that someone who eats a lot the day before the fast has a harder time refraining from eating on the fast day, therefore the person who spends the ninth of Tishrei eating is credited for having additional inuy.

Others point out that Yom Kippur is a holiday, a day on which we really should be eating and drinking.

Since we cannot eat and drink on Yom Kippur, we “make up” for it on erev Yom Kippur.

We explore the halacha of eating on the Erev Yom kippur and the chassidic dimension.

Yoma 80: Bar Yochni

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 80

To download, click/tap here: PDF

Our daf asks: Even if we claim that the measure for impure foods is an egg-bulk, one could say it is referring to the giant egg-bulk of the bird called bar yokhani.

and elsewhere:

Rabbi Yishmael ben Satriel also testified before Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi: Once an egg of the bird called bar yokhani fell, and the contents of the egg drowned sixty cities and broke three hundred cedar trees.

Among Jews, as among most nations (Gubernatis, "Zoological Mythology," on Birds), birds were thought to possess supernatural knowledge, because they soared in the air.

Overall, bird imagery in Semitic literature outside the Old Testament has an imaginative and mystical flare. There’s the giant ziz, the avian equivalent of leviathan and the legends that King Solomon, the wise monarch and son of King David, could understand the language of birds. We have descriptions in The Apocalypse of Abraham, a first- or second-century CE text of pre-Rabbinic Judaism, of the great patriarch and an angel making their way to heaven by aid of a pigeon’s and turtledove’s wings .

And in other writings, we learn that sparrows sing as spirits continue to be born, set forth from the Guf, a mysterious storehouse of souls. However, once the last spirit departs from this realm, the songs of sparrows will cease and the world will soon end.

Yoma 79: כותבת Phoenix Dactylifera

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 79

To download, click/tap here: PDF

We have learned that one of the five forbidden, pleasurable activities on Yom Kippur is eating. The Mishnah (73b) taught that in order to be held liable for eating, one must consume an amount of food the size of a kotevet ha-gasah – a large date. Since this measurement is an unusual one (for example, with regard to birkat ha-mazon – grace after meals – the minimum amount that needs to be eaten is either a kezayit – the size of an olive– or a ka-beitzah – the size of an egg), the Gemara on our daf attempts to define it.

Rava quotes Rav Yehuda asteaching that a kotevet ha-gasah must be larger than an egg, since the Sages determined that only an amount greater than a ka-beitzah size gives a sense of satisfaction. While ordinarily the Sages do not attempt to give explanations for the specific size requirement given by the Torah,

Rabbi Avraham Tiktin, in his DavarBe-ito argues that in this case there was a recognition that the rules of Yom Kippur were left to the Sages to define (see the Ran’s explanation of this phenomenon on page 73b), so we must try and understand their underlying logic.

This leads us to examine the halochos of berocho acharona, and to the extraordinary Israeli scientific achievement of growing seven date palm trees from 2000-year-old seeds found in the Judean desert near Jerusalem.

Yoma 78: Chananya ben Tradyon

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 78

To download, click/tap here: PDF 

Rabbi Ḥananya ben Teradyon says in the name of Rabbi Eliezer: A king and a bride may wash their faces (on Yom Kippur). The Rabbis said: A new mother may not wear shoes on Yom Kippur. Rabbi Ḥananya ben Teradyon says in the name of Rabbi Eliezer: A new mother may wear shoes.

R' Chanina was punished for pronouncing the Tetragrammaton in public, and his wife was punished for not preventing him for doing so.

R' Chanina had two sons and two daughters. One son associated with robbers and was put to death (Eicha Rabah 3:16, 6; Semachot 12:13), and the other was a Torah scholar (Tosefta Kelim 4:9).

His well-known daughter was Beruriah.

Yoma 77: Pulsa Dinura

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 77

To download, click/tap here: PDF

The Holy One Blessed be He said to the angel Michael,"Your nation has sinned!" Michael suggested to spare the nation because of the good ones among them, but the answer was, "I will burn them together with the good ones who did not protest." At this time Gabriel asked another angel, a Cherub, to bring the coals, took those coals and threw them on Jerusalem. However, since the coals cooled somewhat, the nation survived. They gave Gabriel sixty fiery lashes (pulsa dânura) and expelled him.Gabriel continued arguing on behalf of the Jewish people, and when he mentioned Daniel, the Holy One Blessed be He asked, "Who is he that is advocating on behalf of my children?" - and Gabriel was brought back.

We explore the notion of these fiery lashes and some adherents of Kabbalah developed the idea of invoking a curse against a sinner, which they termed pulsa deNura. The source for this modern ritual is not to be found in Kabbalah, but among the Hebrew magical manuals of antiquity, such as Sefer HaRazim and The Sword of Moses.

We attempt to understand how activists performed a “Pulsa Dinura” against Yitzhak Rabin shortly before his death in 1995 and have used it as late as last week on PM Bennett.

Yoma 76: Manna, Nectar, and Ambrosia

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 76

To download, click/tap here: PDF 

Our daf deals with the mannah. The rabbis do not read the manna as an allegory, but as real food provided by God so that the Israelites would not have to toil for their food, and would have the opportunity to study Torah. God’s supporting Israel with manna gave this generation the unique opportunity to study Torah full time.
According to the midrash, manna is the perfect food that gets absorbed into the body entirely, with no extraneous material. In other words, the Israelites would not have needed to defecate while in the wilderness as long as they ate only manna.

The interpretation of manna as a magical food with spiritual import takes a great leap forward in the Zohar, stressing ontological transformation, and viewing the consumption of manna as a method for internalizing divine wisdom, a transmuting of holiness into corporeality, for those who were scions of faith.

Yoma 75: Quail, Craving or Starving?

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 75

To download, click/tap here: PDF

We explore the episode of the Quail in the wilderness and the aggadic interpretations.

Rav Chanin bar Rava teaches that there are four separate birds called slav.We cannot identify each of these birds with certainty, but it appears that they are all members of the pheasant family of birds, which are similar to chickens.The birds mentioned in the Gemara are variously identified as Alectoris, Francolinus, Ammoperdix and Phasianus, all of which have similar body structures and make up a natural family. The pheasant (Phasianus) is raised as poultry in many places. Standard quail – Coturnix coturnix – is the smallest of the birds related to the chicken.

"It is well known that the quail, known to ornithologists as Coturnix coturnix, migrates in huge flocks from Europe to CentralAfrica in the autumn and returns in the spring. A short-tailed game bird of the pheasant family, it flies rapidly at very low altitudes. Due to the long distance involved, the migration is carried out in stages.

The small quails twice each year land exhausted on the Mediterranean shore, where they can easily be captured by hand and by nets in great quantity.

Their flesh and eggs are said to be delicious, and to this day they are a prized food among the local population and are exported as a delicacy to Europe.

The season of the year in which the Israelites encountered the quails fits in precisely with the bird's migratory pattern." (Nahum Sarna, Exploring Exodus pg. 119)

Yoma 74: The Koy, Tragelaphus?

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 74

To download, click/tap here: PDF 

Our daf refers to an animal called a koy which is halfway between domesticated and wild species of quadruped, and debates how far it is subject to the laws governing each category. Scholars are divided on whether the rabbis believed the koy to be a real creature or an imaginary example used for a hypothetical discussion.

Judith Romney Wegner discusses how the koy represents a hybrid:

Yoma 73: “Inuy”

For the source text click/tap here: Yoma 73

To download, click/tap here: PDF 

The Gemara teaches us that the rabbis argued about what of this Mishna is based on Torah law and what is based on rabbinic law. Does it matter what a person eats? Can the food be treiefot? At what point did we make an oath that we would not eat such food - on Mount Sinai? or simply before Yom Kippur? How do we define “inuy” affliction? According to Rashi, the Rabbis set aside certain rabbinic prohibitions in order to increase a person’s mental anguish and thus allow him to better fulfill the mitzva of affliction on Yom Kippur. According to Rashi’s understanding, this talmudic passage contradicts our proposal, for it follows from what he says that the Yom Kippur prohibitions are intended to cause pain and anguish. Most Rishonim, however, understand the passage differently.